Alternatives Assessment under the RMA & Business Case Processes
May 03, 2022
By Richard Peterson and Paula Hunter
In this Resource Management Journal article our authors discuss the Resource Management Act and identify drivers in business case processes
Assessing alternative ways to resolve problems, take advantage of opportunities and fulfil objectives should be a key step in any significant planning process. Under the Resource Management Act 1991 an “alternatives assessment” is required when seeking resource consent for projects with the potential to have significant adverse effects and when seeking a Notice of Requirement. In addition, directive environmental protection policy requirements, the use of effects management hierarchies, and giving effect to Te Mana o Te Wai are expanding the need for detailed and carefully managed alternative assessment processes.
Read the full article in the Resource Management Journal.
Share
-
Richard is focused on providing planning advice—feasibility reports, planning applications, and input into planning regulations.
Contact Richard -
Paula is a ‘big picture’ kind of person, which comes in handy for her role as the technical lead or reviewer for our more complex or high profile planning and consenting projects.
Contact Paula
{
"headline": "Related Ideas",
"link": {
"text":"View More Ideas",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/market\/environment.html"
},
"newTab": false,
"uuid": "781b814f\u002D6fb8\u002D4552\u002D8c3a\u002D54e06a19bff6",
"themeClass": "home-related-items-2",
"tabs": [
{
"headline": "",
"active": true,
"tabLabel": "Slide Card",
"pages": [
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 0 - How does innovative funding unlock climate‑ready infrastructure?",
"link": {
"text":"How does innovative funding unlock climate‑ready infrastructure?",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/how\u002Ddoes\u002Dinnovative\u002Dfunding\u002Dunlock\u002Dclimate\u002Dready\u002Dinfrastructure.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/029\/forest\u002Dfire\u002Dadobestock\u002D1457976923.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "How does innovative funding unlock climate‑ready infrastructure?",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 1 - The role of positive distraction in pediatric design",
"link": {
"text":"The role of positive distraction in pediatric design",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/article\/2026\/role\u002Dpositive\u002Ddistraction\u002Dpediatric\u002Ddesign.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0137\/texas\u002Dchildrens\u002Dhospital\u002Daustin\u002Dnorth\u002D272546.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "The role of positive distraction in pediatric design",
"overwriteSubhead": "Published Article",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 2 - Q&A: How do we advance sustainability in the design industry",
"link": {
"text":"Q\x26A: How do we advance sustainability in the design industry",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/q\u002Da\u002Dhow\u002Ddo\u002Dwe\u002Dadvance\u002Dsustainability\u002Ddesign\u002Dindustry.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0061\/umlauf\u002Dhistoric\u002Dpreservation\u002Dexpansion\u002D275385.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Q\x26A: How do we advance sustainability in the design industry",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 3 - 5 ways a holistic urban signage and wayfinding system can enhance campus and community",
"link": {
"text":"5 ways a holistic urban signage and wayfinding system can enhance campus and community",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/5\u002Dways\u002Dholistic\u002Durban\u002Dsignage\u002Dwayfinding\u002Dsystem\u002Dcan\u002Denhance\u002Dcampus\u002Dcommunity.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/029\/assembly\u002Dsquare\u002Dwayfinding\u002D277452.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "5 ways a holistic urban signage and wayfinding system can enhance campus and community",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 4 - AWWA ACE 2026 Conference: Stantec presentation schedule",
"link": {
"text":"AWWA ACE 2026 Conference: Stantec presentation schedule",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/conference\/awwa\u002Dace\u002D2026\u002Dstantec\u002Dpresentation\u002Dschedule.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/spotlight\/001\/water\u002Dsplashing\u002Dadobestock\u002D191046137.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "AWWA ACE 2026 Conference: Stantec presentation schedule",
"overwriteSubhead": "Conference",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 5 - Unlocking the true potential of carbon capture means diversifying the UK’s approach",
"link": {
"text":"Unlocking the true potential of carbon capture means diversifying the UK’s approach",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/article\/2026\/unlocking\u002Dtrue\u002Dpotential\u002Dcarbon\u002Dcapture\u002Dmeans\u002Ddiversifying\u002Duks\u002Dapproach.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/029\/ferrybridge\u002Dgas\u002Dpower\u002Dstation\u002Dadobestock\u002D693400364.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Unlocking the true potential of carbon capture means diversifying the UK’s approach",
"overwriteSubhead": "Published Article",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 6 - Building envelope design in healthcare goes beyond energy efficiency",
"link": {
"text":"Building envelope design in healthcare goes beyond energy efficiency",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/building\u002Denvelope\u002Ddesign\u002Dhealthcare\u002Dgoes\u002Dbeyond\u002Denergy\u002Defficiency.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0076\/cambridge\u002Dmemorial\u002Dhospital\u002D3.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Building envelope design in healthcare goes beyond energy efficiency",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 7 - WEF Residuals, Biosolids and Treatment Technology Conference: Stantec presenters",
"link": {
"text":"WEF Residuals, Biosolids and Treatment Technology Conference: Stantec presenters",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/conference\/wef\u002Desiduals\u002Dbiosolids\u002Dtreatment\u002Dtechnology\u002Dconference\u002Dstantec\u002Dpresenters.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0135\/piscataway\u002Dbioenergy\u002Dfacility\u002D256686.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "WEF Residuals, Biosolids and Treatment Technology Conference: Stantec presenters",
"overwriteSubhead": "Conference",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 8 - Innovating canola crushing: Unlocking the future of canola production in North America",
"link": {
"text":"Innovating canola crushing: Unlocking the future of canola production in North America",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/innovating\u002Dcanola\u002Dcrushing\u002Dunlocking\u002Dfuture\u002Dcanola\u002Dproduction\u002Dnorth\u002Damerica.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/029\/canola\u002Dfield\u002Dadobestock\u002D243387798.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Innovating canola crushing: Unlocking the future of canola production in North America",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 9 - Q&A: What trends are shaping airports and airport terminal design today?",
"link": {
"text":"Q\x26A: What trends are shaping airports and airport terminal design today?",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/qa\u002Dwhat\u002Dtrends\u002Dare\u002Dshaping\u002Dairports\u002Dairport\u002Dterminal\u002Ddesign\u002Dtoday.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0089\/george\u002Dbush\u002Diah\u002Dterminal\u002Db\u002Dtransformation\u002D275667.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Q\x26A: What trends are shaping airports and airport terminal design today?",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 10 - From pilot to practice: Derisking water innovation",
"link": {
"text":"From pilot to practice: Derisking water innovation",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/video\/2026\/from\u002Dpilot\u002Dto\u002Dpractice\u002Dderisking\u002Dwater\u002Dinnovation.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/video\/0005\/derisking\u002Dwater\u002Dinnovation.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "From pilot to practice: Derisking water innovation",
"overwriteSubhead": "Video",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 11 - Silica dust: Mining’s invisible concern and the next test of leadership",
"link": {
"text":"Silica dust: Mining’s invisible concern and the next test of leadership",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/article\/2026\/silica\u002Ddust\u002Dminings\u002Dinvisible\u002Dconcern\u002Dnext\u002Dtest\u002Dof\u002Dleadership.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/029\/stone\u002Dcrusher\u002Dadobestock\u002D1849531453.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Silica dust: Mining’s invisible concern and the next test of leadership",
"overwriteSubhead": "Published Article",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 12 - Tailings management north of parallel 60",
"link": {
"text":"Tailings management north of parallel 60",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/article\/2026\/tailings\u002Dmanagement\u002Dnorth\u002Dparallel\u002D60.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/pdf\u002Dpromo\u002Dimages\/004\/grise\u002Dfiord\u002Dnunavut\u002Dadobestock\u002D653495458.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Tailings management north of parallel 60",
"overwriteSubhead": "Published Article",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 13 - Finite element thermal analysis of a roller compacted concrete (RCC) dam",
"link": {
"text":"Finite element thermal analysis of a roller compacted concrete (RCC) dam",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/technical\/2026\/finite\u002Delement\u002Dthermal\u002Danalysis\u002Droller\u002Dcompacted\u002Dconcrete\u002Drcc\u002Ddam.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0077\/gross\u002Ddam.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Finite element thermal analysis of a roller compacted concrete (RCC) dam",
"overwriteSubhead": "Technical Paper",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 14 - Design Quarterly Issue 28 | New solutions",
"link": {
"text":"Design Quarterly Issue 28 | New solutions",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/publication\/2026\/design\u002Dquarterly\u002Dissue\u002D28\u002Dnew\u002Dsolutions.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/pdf\u002Dpromo\u002Dimages\/004\/stantec\u002Ddesign\u002Dquarterly\u002Dissue\u002D28.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Design Quarterly Issue 28 | New solutions",
"overwriteSubhead": "Publication",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 15 - Exploring AI’s role in wastewater treatment",
"link": {
"text":"Exploring AI’s role in wastewater treatment",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/video\/2026\/exploring\u002Dai\u002Drole\u002Dwastewater\u002Dtreatment.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/video\/0005\/wastewater\u002Dtreatment\u002Dplant\u002Dadobestock\u002D486166614.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Exploring AI’s role in wastewater treatment",
"overwriteSubhead": "Podcast",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 16 - Pediatric healthcare design: 4 ways to engage children, reduce stress, and improve care",
"link": {
"text":"Pediatric healthcare design: 4 ways to engage children, reduce stress, and improve care",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/pediatric\u002Dhealthcare\u002Ddesign\u002D4\u002Dways\u002Dto\u002Dengage\u002Dchildren\u002Dreduce\u002Dstress\u002Dimprove\u002Dcare.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/projects\/0137\/texas\u002Dchildrens\u002Dhospital\u002Daustin\u002Dnorth\u002D272542.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Pediatric healthcare design: 4 ways to engage children, reduce stress, and improve care",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 17 - Advancing airborne infection control in healthcare: Insights from ASHRAE 241",
"link": {
"text":"Advancing airborne infection control in healthcare: Insights from ASHRAE 241",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/technical\/2026\/advancing\u002Dairborne\u002Dinfection\u002Dcontrol\u002Dhealthcare\u002Dinsights\u002Dfrom\u002Dashrae\u002D241.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/pdf\u002Dpromo\u002Dimages\/004\/hospital\u002Dair\u002Dconditioning\u002Dadobestock\u002D473754935.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Advancing airborne infection control in healthcare: Insights from ASHRAE 241",
"overwriteSubhead": "Technical Paper",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 18 - Microgrids: A shift toward energy independence",
"link": {
"text":"Microgrids: A shift toward energy independence",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/microgrids\u002Dshift\u002Dtoward\u002Denergy\u002Dindependence.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/029\/residential\u002Dneighbourhood\u002Dadobestock\u002D534528164.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Microgrids: A shift toward energy independence",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 19 - Expanding recycled water in Southern California",
"link": {
"text":"Expanding recycled water in Southern California",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/video\/2026\/expanding\u002Drecycled\u002Dwater\u002Dsouthern\u002Dcalifornia.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/stock\/other\/0008\/plastic\u002Dwater\u002Dpipe\u002Dadobestock\u002D274344464 (002).jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Expanding recycled water in Southern California",
"overwriteSubhead": "Podcast",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 20 - Threading the needle: Upgrading the “L” in the heart of urban Chicago",
"link": {
"text":"Threading the needle: Upgrading the “L” in the heart of urban Chicago",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/video\/2026\/threading\u002Dthe\u002Dneedle\u002Dupgrading\u002Dthe\u002Dl\u002Din\u002Dthe\u002Dheart\u002Dof\u002Durban\u002Dchicago.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/video\/0005\/chicago\u002Dred\u002Dpurple\u002Dline\u002Dconstruction.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Threading the needle: Upgrading the “L” in the heart of urban Chicago",
"overwriteSubhead": "Video",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 21 - Underground mining: Exploring the benefits of block caving and panel caving",
"link": {
"text":"Underground mining: Exploring the benefits of block caving and panel caving",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/underground\u002Dmining\u002Dexploring\u002Dbenefits\u002Dof\u002Dblock\u002Dcaving\u002Dpanel\u002Dcaving.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/pdf\u002Dpromo\u002Dimages\/003\/underground\u002Dmine\u002Dadobestock\u002D251181904.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Underground mining: Exploring the benefits of block caving and panel caving",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 22 - Managing mine water",
"link": {
"text":"Managing mine water",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/article\/2026\/managing\u002Dmine\u002Dwater.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/028\/huntly\u002Dquarries\u002Dadobestock\u002D978496401.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Managing mine water",
"overwriteSubhead": "Published Article",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
},
{
"pageExists": true,
"cardLabel": "Slide Card 23 - Integrating data to unlock optimized coal ash management planning",
"link": {
"text":"Integrating data to unlock optimized coal ash management planning",
"url":"\/en\/ideas\/content\/blog\/2026\/integrating\u002Ddata\u002Dto\u002Dunlock\u002Doptimized\u002Dcoal\u002Dash\u002Dmanagement\u002Dplanning.html"
},
"promoImage": "\/content\/dam\/stantec\/images\/ideas\/blogs\/028\/coal\u002Dfired\u002Dpower\u002Dadobestock\u002D279271484.jpg",
"overwriteHeadline": "Integrating data to unlock optimized coal ash management planning",
"overwriteSubhead": "Blog Post",
"aorLabel": "Architect",
"architectOfRecord": ""
}
]
},
{
"headline": "",
"active": false,
"tabLabel": "Slide Card",
"pages": [
]
},
{
"headline": "",
"active": false,
"tabLabel": "Slide Card",
"pages": [
]
}
]
}